Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Fish Stores and Markets on Long Island, NY

Updated Oct 05 2014 04:20 PM EST with 72 listings

You will find many useful business listings for fish stores and fish markets on Long Island. Our listings below mainly cover Long Island up to the east end townships. CitiDexLI has organized complete guides for the east end of Long Island on www.citidexli-eastend.com and specific links to catering on the east end can be found at the bottom of this page.

Fish Stores and Markets on Long Island, NY

Amagansett Seafood Store

517 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-6015

Bayview Seafood Market

Bay St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-0740

Blue Water Seafood

Route 25, Mattituck NY 11952 Tel 631-298-5960

Braun Seafood CO

30840 Main Rd., Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-6700

Clamann Seafood Market

Seafood market with fresh caught fish, shrimp, clams, mussels, caviares; complete catering services provide delicious seafood, tents, china / flatware, linens, lighting, decorations, entertainment, and all other event needs.
235 -A North Sea Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-3354
Tel: 631-283-6669; Website: clamman.com

Clamman

50 Jagger Lane, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-7705

Clamman Seafood Market Caterer

Featuring fresh seafood and lobster
235 N. Nassau Ave., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6437

Claws on Wheels

27 Race Lane, East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-5090

Coastal Farms

Middle Line Highway, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-3154

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

41 Smith St., Shelter Island NY 11964 Tel 631-749-1851

Danowski's Fish MKT

853 West Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-3990

Duryea's Retail Seafood Market

Tuthill Rd., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-2121

Fish Express

123 Sterling Ave., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-4907

Fish Farm

Fish raised and sold locally and nationwide, owner of Multi Aqua Culture Systems Restaurant
429 Cranberry Hole Rd., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-3341

Gallo's Seafood

1175 E Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-8541

George Braun Oyster Co.

Main Rd., Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-6700

Gosman's Wholesale Seafood Fish Market

West Lake Dr., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-2447

Greenport Seafood Dock - Greenport

222 Atlantic Ave., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-8485

Greenport Seafood Dock - Greenport

222 Atlantic Ave., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 63144770055

Huntington Bay Seafood

We feature a wide assortment of wild caught seafood, seasoned fish, shellfish and soup. Fish Market Huntington Station Long Island NY
225 Walt Whitman Rd, Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-923-0176
E-mail: contact@huntingtonbayseafood.com; Website: huntingtonbayseafood.com

Iceberg Seafood

74 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-1100

Islander Seafood

47 Mayfair Dr., Huntington NY 11743 Tel 631-423-1363

Jeff's Seafood

Serving lunch & dinner, take-out and catering available.
170 New York Ave. (110 no./25A), Halesite NY 11743 Tel 631-427-5120

K & B Seafood

176 Laurel Rd., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-261-8161

Marty's Gourmet Seafood

Open 7 days, fish market with fresh fish as well as cooked seafood dishes. All cooking done on premises, outside seasonal clam bar.
266 New York Ave. (110 no./25A), Huntington Village NY 11743 Tel 631-673-1888

Mattituck Fishing Station

1404 Naugles Dr, Mattituck NY 11952 Tel 631-298-8399

Montauk Inlet Seafood

New York's largest commercial fish dock.
East Lake Dr., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-3419

Northport Fish & Lobster

Huge variety of fresh fish, fresh live Maine lobsters daily, fresh clams, catering in Northport NY
827 Fort Salonga Rd., Northport NY 11768 Tel 631-757-3474

Noyac Bay Fish Market

590 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-4712

Off the Hook Seafood Market and Grill

The freshest fish, seafood, shellfish, crabs, clams, mussels in East Northport NY. Take a peak at what we have to offer in our Fresh Seafood Market
1965 Jericho Tpk., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-858-2393
Fax: 631-858-2394; Website: offthehookseafoodmarket.com

Seafood Take Out at Southold Fish Market

Southhold NY 11971 Tel 631-765-3200
Website: stuartsseafood.com

Shrimp Boutique

905 East Jericho Tpk., Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-351-3474

Tully's Lobster & Seafood Market

78 Foster Ave., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-9043

Von Hassel's

Main Rd., Mattituck NY 11944 Tel 631-298-4116

Warren's Tackle Center

Main Rd., Aquebogue NY 11931 Tel 631-722-4898

White A P Bait Shop - Greenport

3501 1st St., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-0008

White A P Bait Shop - Greenport

3501 1st St., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-0008

Woodbury Fishery

Long Island NY Fish Market Woodbury
8049 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury NY 11797 Woodbury Country Square, Tel 516-496-2016
Fax: 516-921-3549; Website: woodburyfish.com

Fish Stores-retail (27 listings total)

Alice's Fish Market

Call ahead for "Today's Catch" and fax in your order for pickup.
222 Atlantic Ave., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-8485

Amagansett Seafood Store

517 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-6015

Bennett Seafood Market

11 Parlato Pl., Westhampton Beach NY 11978 Tel 631-288-2573
E-mail: webmaster@bennettseafood.com; Website: bennettseafood.com

Braun Seafood Company

The finest seafoods produced from Long Island waters and surrounding areas, wide variety of fresh and frozen fishes.
25500 Main Rd., Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-7770
Website: braunseafood.com

Brewsters Seafood Market & Restaurant

Specializing in fresh seafood and shellfish located off of Canoe Place Rd
252 East Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-3474
Website: nyseafood.com

Catch & Cut, Inc.

552 East Jericho Tpk., Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-351-1645

Citarella

Specializing in fresh seafood, this one of a kind market will help you plan and cater any celebration.
Order 212-874-0383
E-mail: services@citarella.com; Website: citarella.com

Citarella - East Hampton

Main St., East Hampton NY Tel 631-324-9190

Citarella - Water Mill

Fish and gourmet foods are featured at Citerella located in Watermill Long Island corporate mailing add: 2135 Broadway New York, NY 10023
760 Montauk Hwy., Water Mill NY 11976 Tel 631-726-3636

Clamman

There are cases of super-fresh fish and shellfish in all varieties, as well as sauces, vinegars, prepared soups, and a case of frozen dishes.
235 -A North Sea Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6437
Tel: 631-283-6669

Claudio's Crabby Jerry's

111 Main St., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-8252

Coastal Farms

Middle Line Highway, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-3154

Cor-J Seafood

Retail and wholesale with a large selection of whole fish, fish fillets, shrimps, lobster and clams.
36 Lighthouse Rd., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-5186
Tel: 631-728-5187

Cor-J Seafood of West Hampton

214 Mill Rd., Westhampton Beach NY 11978 Tel 631-288-8184

Danny's Fish & Lobster

572 Larkfield Rd., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-266-1141

Depot Fish & Chip Market

212 Depot Rd., Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-425-4862

Duryea's Retail Seafood Market

Tuthill Rd., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-2121

East End Clambakes

You'll find fresh steamer, fried clam and shrimp platters, lobster rolls, and even grilled yellowfin tuna.
590 Country Rd. 39, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-726-5360
Tel: 631-726-6351; E-mail: captphilgay@aol.com
Website: hamptons.com

Fish & Co.

113 W Broadway., Port Jefferson NY 11777 Tel 631-473-1764

Gallo's Seafood

1175 E Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-8541

Gosman's Fish Market

You'll find tanks of clams, oysters, and lobsters and cases of shrimp, salmon, bass, flounder, tuna, shark, and just about anything else-fresh from the fishing boats.
484 West Lake Dr., Montauk NY 11954 P.O. Box 2340, Tel 631-668-5645

Greenport Seafood Dock

222 Atlantic Ave., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 63144770055

Iceberg Seafood

74 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-1100

Jeff & Eddy's Seafood

Moderately priced New England-style, casual seafood joint and an auxiliary seafood market. Come early for that fresh-from-the-boat fin food.
62 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-0055
E-mail: jeff@jeffeddys.com; Website: jeffeddys.com

Seafood Shop

A wide array of fresh fish and shellfish. Crew of fishmongers who will fillet a whole fish, cut custom-ordered fish steaks, or prepare just about any other special order that you may want.
356 Montauk Hwy., Wainscott NY 11975 Tel 631-537-0633
Fax: 631-537-5430

Seafood Take Out at Southold Fish Market

Southhold NY 11971 Tel 631-765-3200
Website: stuartsseafood.com

Stuart's Seafood Market

There's a good seafood selection, with fresh shellfish still in their watery tank.
41 Oak Lane, Amagansett NY Tel 631-267-6700
Tel: 631-375-7744; Fax: 631-267-6709
E-mail: stuartsseafood@optonline.net; Website: stuartsseafood.com

Fish Markets-wholesale (7 listings total)

Braun Seafood Company

The finest seafoods produced from Long Island waters and surrounding areas, wide variety of fresh and frozen fishes.
25500 Main Rd., Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-7770
Website: braunseafood.com

Danowski's Fish MKT

853 West Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-3990

Fish Farm

Fish raised and sold locally and nationwide, owner of Multi Aqua Culture Systems Restaurant
429 Cranberry Hole Rd., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-3341

George Braun Oyster Co.

Main Rd., Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-6700

Gosman's Wholesale Seafood Fish Market

West Lake Dr., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-2447

Ocean Dynasty Wholesale Seafood

410 Lexington Ave., North Babylon NY 11703 North Babylon, Tel 631-587-4693

Tully's Lobster & Seafood Market

78 Foster Ave., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-9043

Specific links for fish stores and fish markets on the east end of Long Island:
Fish Markets in Hamptons NY, North Fork Long Island fish market, Fish stores Montauk and Shelter Island NY.