Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Thrift Store on Long Island, NY Consignment Shops

Updated Oct 05 2014 04:20 PM EST with 39 listings
Thrift shops and consignment shops are great places to pick up unusual finds, gently used clothing and furniture at bargain prices. Many are operated by churches and organizations that service the community.
When moving there are several ways a thrift shop or consignment store can come in handy. Places like Cooky's Thrift and Consignment in Oceanside Long Island are a great place to put furniture, fur coats, or evening gowns that you will no longer make use of on consignment. If you have just moved into an apartment in the Cedarhurst, NY area you may not have the funds to completely furnish it. A consignment shop or local thrift shop such as Plum A Resale Boutique Thrift Shop may have some gently used furniture available for purchase.
Thrift Store on Long Island, NY Consignment Shops

Act II Consignment Boutique

Designer clothing & accessories at a fraction of their original cost.
11 Hewitt Square, East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-754-1800

American Cancer Society Thrift Shop

The American Cancer Society is the nationwide community-based voluntary health organization dedicated to eliminating cancer as a major health problem by preventing cancer, saving lives from cancer and diminishing suffering from cancer through research, education, advocacy and service.
22 Nugent St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6789
Website: cancer.org

Animal Rescue Fund Thrift Shop

132 W. Montauk Highway, Water Mill NY 11976 Tel 631-726-6613

Antiques / Consignment

A small, yet respectable antiques shop located in Carle Place, New York 11514. This store is not only full of antiques, but it doubles as a consignment shop, which buys your items from you, so everyone makes money!
568 Westbury Ave., Carle Place NY 11514 General Info 516-286-6682
Pager/Beeper: 516-648-0733

Birthright's Red Barn Thrift Shoppe

Sponsored by Birthright, a non-profit, non-denominational charity agency offering aid to pregnant women and their unborn children; thrift shop includes art, antiques, china, furniture, fabric, clothing, cribs, hi-chairs, and other baby & maternal supplies.
675 -B North Sea Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-287-6456
Tel: 800-550-4900

Collette Designer Consignment

10 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-1867

Community Thrift Shop

Huntington Long Island NY Mostly clothing, but you can find other treasures here as well This shop benefits local charities: Family Service League, Visiting Nurses, Red Cross, Planned Parenthood, Huntington Hospital, Pederson-Krag Center and Cancer Care
274 New York Avenue, Huntington Village NY 11743 Tel 631-271-4883

Consignment Shop

29 Front St., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-1062

Dominican Sisters Thrift Shop

Proceeds benefit the Dominican Sisters Family Health Service.
Washington St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-728-0937

East End Hospice Thrift

58 Riverhead Rd., Westhampton Beach NY 11978 Tel 631-288-3268

ELI Hospital Opportunity Shop

321 Main St., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-1120

Fab Finds Ltd

Greenlawn Long Island NY Thrift Shop, Consignment, and internet auction services sell it on ebay, complete estate sale servie antiques and collectables bought and sold
54 Broadway, Greenlawn NY 11740 Tel 631-261-0477
E-mail: fabfindsltd@aol.com

GiGi's Kids - The Kid's Consignment Shop

New and gently used clothing & toys.
48 -A West Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-723-2864
E-mail: info@gigiskids.com; Website: gigiskids.com

Glory Hole Thrift Shop

Main Rd., Southold NY 11971

Goodwill Store

Clothing, shoes and household goods
1900 Jericho Tpk., East Northport NY 11731 Elwood Shopping Center, Tel 631-462-4219

Holiday House Thrift Shop

All proceeds go directly to the Holiday House Camp for "girls in need".
74 Huntington Rd., Huntington Village NY 11743 Tel 631-427-2944

LVIS Bargin Box

95 Main St., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-1370


7 Spring St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631725

New Suffolk Emporium

1st St., New Suffolk NY 11956 Tel 631-734-6677

North Fork Parish Outreach

54895 Main Rd., Southold NY 11971 Tel 631-765-1776

North Shore Holiday House

This thrift shop benefits Holiday House which provides a sleep away camp experience for girls. The shop is closed during the summer months when the building is used by the campers. From Sept- June the thrift shop is open.
74 Huntington Rd., Huntington NY 11743 Tel 631-427-7630
Fax: 631-470-9727; Website: www.nshh.org

Once Upon a Time

Under management of Shoe Vixen owner. Great gently worn designer clothes, shoes and accessories.
485 Montauk Hwy., East Quogue NY 11942 Tel 631-653-8197

Options Thrift Shop

Thrift shop at the Social Community Living Service
392 Hawkins Ave., Lake Ronkonkoma NY 11779 Tel 631-981-7626
Website: optionscl.org

P J's Second Time Around Store

1518 Main St., Port Jefferson NY 11777 Tel 631-331-1276

Parish Resource Center

Rocky Point Long Island New York non-denominational organization that works with congregations and idividuals in Suffolk County providing trained staff, workshops, and resouces to assist with programs and activities in your congregation
89 Hallock Landing Road, Rocky Point NY 11778 Tel 631-821-2255
Tel: 631-928-1206; E-mail: info@prcli.org
Website: prcli.org

Renaissance Resale

42 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-287-6320

Reuben Home On Consignment

A wide selection of items to choose from at great prices.
25 Madison St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-6160

Salvation Army Thrift - East Northport

Huge! If you're a thrift maniac, go here alone! No one else will have the patience.
110 Bellerose Ave., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-754-4449
Website: salvationarmy.org

Salvation Army Thrift - East Northport

319 Clay Pitts Rd., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-368-1170
Fax: 631-368-1232; Website: salvationarmy-newyork.org

Salvation Army Thrift - Riverhead

319 E Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-1571

Salvation Army Thrift - Riverhead

130 Osborne Ave, Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-3338
Website: salvationarmy.org

Society of St. Vincent De Paul Furniture Thrift Store

Come see all the hidden treasures that can be yours!
1705 Jericho Tpk., Huntington NY 11743 Tel 631-858-0380

Southampton Hospital Thrift Shop

Conveniently located within Southampton Hospital.
79 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-204-0526
Website: southamptonhospital.org

St. Ann's Thrift Shop

Main St., Bridgehampton NY 11932 Tel 631-537-5150

St. Paul's Thrift Shop

280 Main St., Northport Village NY 11768 Tel 631-262-9167

St. Vincent De Paul Society Thrift Shop

Nearly new clothing, shoes and household items
1425 New York Ave. (110 so./25A), Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-385-1226

Stony Brook Community Church Opportunity Shop

218 Christian Ave., Stony Brook NY 11790 Tel 631-751-9733

Take It or Leave It

4 Midland Avenue, Quogue NY 11959 Tel 631-653-4475

Welcome Home Aids

70 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-287-4188
Buying from Long Island thrift shops can be a very rewarding experience. Many thrift shops will donate a percentage of their income to a particular charity. Others might be run by churches and hospitals. Popular things to buy at a Long Island thrift shop are furniture, clothes, televisions, and even kitchen appliances. For the savy-web user, eBay is the perfect online thrift shop. One can log in and start bidding on auctions that many times are cheaper then the thrift store, and even cheaper than the original price.