Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Restaurants on The South Shore: Suffolk From Islip To Bayport

Updated Oct 05 2014 04:20 PM EST with 25 listings
Restaurants on The South Shore: Suffolk From Islip To Bayport

21 Main Prime Steak House

Typical first quality steakhouse located in a historic mansion, serving creative meals and diverse selection of excellent vintage wines
21 Montauk Hwy., West Sayville NY 11796 Tel 631-567-0900
Fax: 631-567-5002; Website: 21main.com


Seafood eatery.
Ocean Beach NY 11706 Bayview & Denhoff, Tel 631-583-5697

As Time Goes By Restaurant & Piano Bar

Brightwaters NY 391 N. Windsor Ave., Tel 631-666-2377

Bayport House

Just like a country inn upstate... - Zagats 2002 Long Island Restaurants
Bayport NY 291 Bayport Ave., Tel 631-472-2444

Beachtree Restaurant - Bar

Great Sunday brunch menu, varied appetizer and dinner menu, soups, salads, sandwiches. Special early dinner menu Mo-Fr from 3:30pm-5:30pm.
166 W Main Street, East Islip NY 11730 Tel 631-277-4800
Fax: 631-224-4695; Website: beachtreerestaurant.com

Bocce Beach Restaurant

937 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach NY Tel 631-583-8100

Brick & Rail

Just opened restaurant in Wantagh NY offering newest dinning experience, private parties and catering available
3274 Railroad Ave., Wantagh NY 11793 Tel 516-308-3476


Innovative, delicious gourmet - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants
154 Montauk Hwy., Babylon Village NY Blue Point Village Commons, Tel 631-363-0500

CJ's Allegro

Authentic Italian-American food.
479 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach NY 11770 Tel 631-583-9890

Collins & Main

Sophisticated dishes and upscale decor
100 Old South Main St, Sayville NY 11782 Tel 631-563-0805


Popular bar and restaurant located on the bay at the Ocean Bay Park ferry terminal attracting a young and boisterous crowd on the weekends.
1 Cayuga St., Ocean Bay Park NY 11770 Tel 631-583-9300

in season american bistro

Charming, comfortable Tuscan decor; "guaranteed Italian" cuisine.
301 Main St., Islip NY 11751 Tel 631-581-1029
Website: nuvolariislip.com

Le Soir

Bayport Long Island New York Authentic and delicious classic French cuisine
825 Montauk Hwy., Bayport NY 11705 Bayport Ave., Tel 631-472-9090


Old fashioned Italian dining
587 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale NY 11769 LaSalle Commons Dale Dr , Tel 631-589-9640
Website: theoriginalmamas.com

Mama's *

Old fashioned Italian dining
587 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale NY 11769 LaSalle Commons, Tel 631-589-9640
Website: theoriginalmamas.com

Matthew's Seafood House

Family owned seafood restaurant on the bay serving seafood platters, pasta and sandwiches, great sunset views.
935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach NY 11770 Tel 631-583-8016

Out Restaurant, The

Bay Walk, Fair Harbor NY Tel 631-583-7400

Popei's Clam Bar

Famous for seafood and all you can eat specials.

Popei's Clam Bar - Sayville

299 Raft Ave., Sayville NY Tel 631-567-9054

Rachel's Restaurant

Ocean-side seafood restaurant, chowders, various fried fish platters.
Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove NY Fire Island, Tel 631-597-4174
E-mail: jlangar@aol.com; Website: rachelsrestaurant.com

Riverview Restaurant

Spectacular views and beautiful decor
3 Consuelo Pl., Oakdale NY 11769 (South of Shore Dr.), Tel 631-589-2694
Website: lessing.com

Snapper Inn

Broad Seafood Menu.
500 Shore Dr., Oakdale NY 11769 Tel 500

Sole Luna Cafe

310 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach NY Tel 631-583-7337

The Gatsby Lounge

A fine American food restaurant serving elegant meals and cocktails in a historic South shore mansion; live music, DJ dance party, and other musical performances for a mature (25+) and well-dressed crowd.
712 Main St., Islip NY 11751 Tel 631-581-1900
Website: thegatsby.com

Yacht Club, The

Serving lunch and dinner on a spacious dock-side deck.
Harbor Walk, Fire Island Pines NY Tel 631-597-6131